12 shops, 56 847 products

Comparison: Uniroyal MS plus 77 vs. Firestone Winterhawk 3 vs. Petlas Snowmaster W651 vs. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 vs. Semperit Speed-Grip 3

Table of contents:

Summary
Wet
Dry
Snow
Ice
Costs
Mutual tests
Buy %

#	Uniroyal MS plus 77 /0%	Firestone Winterhawk 3 /0%	Petlas Snowmaster W651 /14%	Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 /100%	Semperit Speed-Grip 3 /0%

Dimensions	R13 - R19	R13 - R18	R15 - R18	R16 - R22	R15 - R20
Price	Set dimension to see prices	Set dimension to see prices	Set dimension to see prices	Set dimension to see prices	Set dimension to see prices
Remove	Remove from comparison	Remove from comparison	Remove from comparison	Remove from comparison	Remove from comparison

Segment

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 Premium

2. Uniroyal MS plus 77 Upper-middle

3. Firestone Winterhawk 3 Upper-middle

4. Petlas Snowmaster W651 Lowcost

5. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 Lowcost

Number of sizes available

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 133

2. Uniroyal MS plus 77 76

3. Firestone Winterhawk 3 66

4. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 51

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 11

Number of tests

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 21x

2. Uniroyal MS plus 77 19x

3. Firestone Winterhawk 3 14x

4. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 11x

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 6x

Best position in test

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 1.

2. Firestone Winterhawk 3 3.

3. Uniroyal MS plus 77 3.

4. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 3.

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 9.

Worst position in test

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 4.

2. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 15.

3. Uniroyal MS plus 77 17.

4. Firestone Winterhawk 3 32.

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 50.

Average position in tests

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 1.67

2. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 7.64

3. Uniroyal MS plus 77 11.21

4. Firestone Winterhawk 3 16

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 38

Year of the last test

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 2025

2. Petlas Snowmaster W651 2023

3. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 2021

4. Firestone Winterhawk 3 2020

5. Uniroyal MS plus 77 2020

Best rating in test

1. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 Exemplary

2. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 Exemplary

3. Firestone Winterhawk 3 Satisfactory

4. Uniroyal MS plus 77 Satisfactory

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 ?

Worst rating in test

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 Good

2. Uniroyal MS plus 77 Satisfactory

3. Firestone Winterhawk 3 Conditionally recommended

4. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 Sufficient

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 ?

Wet

(Overall rating)

Uniroyal
MS plus 77

82%

Semperit
Speed-Grip 3

76.1%

Michelin
PILOT ALPIN 5

71.8%

Firestone
Winterhawk 3

70%

Petlas
Snowmaster W651

37.2%

Wet braking according to EU label

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 B

2. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 C

3. Firestone Winterhawk 3 C

4. Uniroyal MS plus 77 ?

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 ?

Snow

(Overall rating)

Petlas
Snowmaster W651

97.6%

Michelin
PILOT ALPIN 5

85.1%

Firestone
Winterhawk 3

81%

Uniroyal
MS plus 77

80%

Semperit
Speed-Grip 3

75.2%

Costs

(Overall rating)

Firestone
Winterhawk 3

81%

Uniroyal
MS plus 77

78%

Semperit
Speed-Grip 3

77.7%

Michelin
PILOT ALPIN 5

76.2%

Petlas
Snowmaster W651

0%

Fuel consumption according to EU label

1. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 C

2. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 D

3. Firestone Winterhawk 3 E

4. Uniroyal MS plus 77 ?

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 ?

Comfort

(Overall rating)

Semperit
Speed-Grip 3

78.2%

Michelin
PILOT ALPIN 5

78.9%

Firestone
Winterhawk 3

75%

Uniroyal
MS plus 77

75%

Petlas
Snowmaster W651

0%

Outside noise accoring to EU label

1. Semperit Speed-Grip 3 ?

2. Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 ?

3. Firestone Winterhawk 3 ?

4. Uniroyal MS plus 77 ?

5. Petlas Snowmaster W651 ?

Dry

(Overall rating)

Michelin
PILOT ALPIN 5

85.8%

Firestone
Winterhawk 3

75%

Uniroyal
MS plus 77

74%

Semperit
Speed-Grip 3

69.8%

Petlas
Snowmaster W651

62.5%

Ice

(Overall rating)

Firestone
Winterhawk 3

89%

Semperit
Speed-Grip 3

83.3%

Uniroyal
MS plus 77

77%

Michelin
PILOT ALPIN 5

64.5%

Petlas
Snowmaster W651

0%

Add to comparison

Make

Model

Mutual Tests Available

These tyres were tested together in 11 test(s). Click to view detailed head-to-head results.

Mutual tests

Autobild Winter tyre test 2020 245/45 R18

Name	Stopping distance on wet	Stopping distance on snow
Best values in test	30,3	24,3
Uniroyal MS plus 77	34,2	25
Firestone Winterhawk 3	37,9
Petlas Snowmaster W651	43,1
Michelin Pilot Alpin 5	31,9	24,3
Semperit Speed-Grip 3	30,8	26
Show test details

Autobild Winter tyre test 2019 225/45 R17

Name	Stopping distance on wet	Stopping distance on snow
Best values in test	29,2	24
Uniroyal MS plus 77	32,8	24,6
Firestone Winterhawk 3	34,3	25,5
Semperit Speed-Grip 3	31,6	24,3
Show test details

Autobild Winter tyre test 2018 195/65 R15

Name	Wet	Dry	Snow	Running costs
Best values in test	1-	2+	1	1
Uniroyal MS plus 77 Rating: Satisfactory	2	3	2	2
Firestone Winterhawk 3 Rating: Conditionally recommended	3	3+	2+	2+
Show test details

Autobild Winter tyre test 2018 195/65 R15

Name	Stopping distance on wet	Stopping distance on snow
Best values in test	34,3	27
Uniroyal MS plus 77	36,1	27,9
Firestone Winterhawk 3	38,2	27,8
Show test details

Autobild Winter tyre test 2017 225/50 R17

Name	Wet	Dry	Snow	Running costs
Best values in test	2+	2+	1	2+
Uniroyal MS plus 77 Rating: Satisfactory	2-	2-	2	2+
Firestone Winterhawk 3 Rating: Satisfactory	3+	2	2	2-
Semperit Speed-Grip 3 Rating: Good	2	2	2+	2-
Show test details

Autobild Winter tyre test 2017 225/50 R17

Name	Stopping distance on wet	Stopping distance on snow
Best values in test	32,2	25,9
Uniroyal MS plus 77	36	28,1
Firestone Winterhawk 3	36,3	27,9
Semperit Speed-Grip 3	34,4	27,4
Show test details

Autobild Winter tyre test 2016 205/55 R16

Name	Stopping distance on wet	Stopping distance on snow
Best values in test	34,2	25
Uniroyal MS plus 77	39,1	25,7
Firestone Winterhawk 3	39,8	27,5
Petlas Snowmaster W651	43,3	-
Show test details

ADAC Winter tyre test 2016 225/45 R17

Name	Wet	Dry	Snow	Ice	Noise	Wear	Fuel consumption
Best values in test	2,3	2,1	1,7	2,0	2,8	1,5	1,5
Uniroyal MS plus 77 Rating: -	2,3	3,2	2,5	2,6	3,1	2,5	1,9
Firestone Winterhawk 3 Rating: -	3,0	2,9	2,4	2,0	2,8	2,0	2,2
Show test details

ADAC Winter tyre test 2016 185/65 R15

Name	Wet	Dry	Snow	Ice	Noise	Wear	Fuel consumption
Best values in test	1,8	1,9	1,7	2,2	2,8	1	1,5
Uniroyal MS plus 77 Rating: -	2,7	3,3	1,7	2,9	3,7	2,5	2,0
Firestone Winterhawk 3 Rating: -	4,6	2,3	2,8	2,6	3,0	2,0	1,8
Show test details