Comparison: Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde vs. Michelin Energy Saver +

Let's delve into the world of tyres. Today, we're comparing two powerhouse options: the Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde and the Michelin Energy Saver +. Both are summer tyres, emphasising warm-weather performance and fuel efficiency - but how do they fare in direct comparison and third-party tests?

Starting with the Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde, these tyres tout an impressive performance rating of 47% from our internal reviews. Looking at mutual tests, they managed to snag the 4th place out of 51 tyres in Autobild's rigorous testing environment, and even landed the top spot in ADAC's test. This strong showing indicates the P1's ability to deliver consistent, superior performance across various conditions, reinforcing Pirelli's reputation for quality and reliability.

Shifting to the Michelin Energy Saver +, these tyres unfortunately scored a low 0% rating in our internal reviews. They also had a lukewarm performance in third-party tests, ranking 15th out of 51 tyres in Autobild's test and 11th out of 16 in ADAC's test. While not disastrous, these results certainly leave room for improvement. Perhaps Michelin's Energy Saver + is better suited to specific, low-demand conditions, but in terms of all-around performance, they struggle to compete with the Pirellis.

However, it's important to note that the Michelin Energy Saver + is one of the brand's more budget-friendly options, which could factor into its lower performance figures. Conversely, the Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde is positioned as a high-performance, premium offering, reflected in its higher pricing and performance ratings. In terms of replacements, neither tyre has been directly replaced by a newer model yet, reflecting their continued popularity and relevance in the respective companies' lineups.

In conclusion, the superior performance of the Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde gives it the edge in this comparison. While both tyres have their merits and potential use cases, for those seeking high performance and fuel efficiency, the Pirelli model stands out as the more reliable choice. However, the budget-conscious or light usage driver might still find value in the Michelin Energy Saver +.