Comparison: Maxxis Premitra AS AP3 vs. Dunlop Sport All Season

When comparing the Maxxis Premitra AS AP3 and the Dunlop Sport All Season tyres, several elements stand out. Manufactured by Maxxis and Dunlop respectively, these tyres have proven to be reliable choices for all-round usage.

The Maxxis Premitra AS AP3, produced in China, ranks well in tests with a 53% quality rating. It particularly stood out in wet circle cornering and exterior noise, offering a smooth and quiet ride. The 7th position ranking in Autobild's test, out of 32 total tyres, showcases the AP3's worthwhile performance. However, its weaknesses according to the Autobild 2022 summary included a delayed steering response and a tendency to understeer in all weather conditions. A restricted tread life and economy were also noted.

On the other hand, the Dunlop Sport All Season produced in France, scored a noticeably higher quality rating of 62%. This tyre excelled in the Autobild test — earning a 6th ranking — notably for dry handling, comfort, wet circle cornering, and aquaplaning resistance both cross and longitudinal. Though praised as an all-rounder with dynamic wet handling and good safety reserves against aquaplaning in curves, the Dunlop was found to have understeering snow handling and a slightly elongated dry braking distance.

To summarise, the Maxxis Premitra AS AP3 offers very good aquaplaning qualities at an affordable price. While it does have its drawbacks, it does still account for a smooth and quiet ride. Meanwhile, the Dunlop Sport All Season provides a dynamic performance under wet conditions and offers the best comfort, making it a worthy all-round tyre. Despite slight drawbacks in snow handling and dry braking distance, it stands out for its dry handling and overall performance.

So, in terms of overall test performance, the Dunlop Sport All Season tends to edge out the Maxxis Premitra AS AP3. However, both have their strengths, and your choice will depend on your specific needs and driving conditions.