Comparison: Vredestein Quatrac 5 vs. Nokian WeatherProof

In the world of all-round tyres, two standout models have often been put to the test - the Vredestein Quatrac 5 and the Nokian WeatherProof. Both tyres have been tested extensively, but let's delve a little deeper to see how they truly measure up.

The Vredestein Quatrac 5, a product of Dutch manufacturer Vredestein, performed admirably in a range of tests. According to tests conducted by AutoBild and ADAC, it particularly excelled in its exterior noise level and also displayed excellent dry driving behaviour and safety functionalities, as well as an impressive performance in interior noise control.

However, the Quatrac 5 did not always outrank its competitors. For example, its overall position in the AutoMotorSport, Autozeitung and Gute-Fahrt tests ranked fifth, sixth and eighth respectively, out of seven, ten and nine total tyres tested in these cases.

On the other hand, the Nokian WeatherProof - a product hailing from Finnish tyre manufacturer Nokian - outperformed most of its competitors. It not only resisted aquaplaning (both cross and longitudinal) but also showcased significant strength in areas such as snow braking, snow handling and rolling resistance.

By virtue of the ACE and AutoExpress tests, the WeatherProof even took the number one spot, outperforming six and nine other tyres respectively. Though this was not always the case, as it took third and fourth positions in other tests like Autozeitung and Gute-Fahrt.

In terms of ratings, the Vredestein Quatrac 5 received ours at 36%, while the Nokian WeatherProof came out ahead with a rating of 59%. This puts both tyres in the high-performance tier but shows a clear edge for the WeatherProof model.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a tyre with less noise and solid dry driving behaviour, you might seriously consider the Vredestein Quatrac 5. However, if you prioritise aquaplaning resistance, snow handling, and overall great performance against various criteria, the Nokian WeatherProof is a proven powerhouse. Each has its strengths, and the best tyre for you will ultimately depend on your individual driving needs and environmental conditions.