Comparison: Toyo Celsius AS2 vs. Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3

The head-to-head all-season comparison between the Toyo Celsius AS2 and the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 shows a clear performance gap across independent tests. Both tyres are marketed as all-round solutions, but independent Autobild tests and our aggregate rating expose markedly different strengths and weaknesses.

Test summary & overall scores: the Pirelli scores very high in our database (94%) and consistently ranks at the top in Autobild test runs (1st and 2nd place in separate test groups). The Toyo records a much lower overall score (54%) and finished near the back in the same Autobild comparisons (10th of 11 and 12th of 37). In short: Pirelli dominates the test charts; Toyo underperforms relative to the class.

Toyo Celsius AS2 — strengths and weaknesses

• Strengths: noted for comfort and value — Autobild repeatedly flags the Celsius AS2 for ride comfort and competitive pricing. Test notes also list stable dry handling, short braking distances on snow, and low rolling resistance as positives.


• Weaknesses: winter and wet performance are only satisfactory: Autobild mentions understeering in snow/wet conditions and extended wet braking distances. In larger comparison groups the AS2 finished in the lower third, showing that its all-season capability is limited under demanding wet and winter test scenarios.


• Use case: a reasonable option if you prioritise comfort, low cost and rolling-efficiency for mainly dry to mild-season driving, but not the best choice if frequent heavy rain or winter conditions are expected.

Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 — strengths and weaknesses

• Strengths: outstanding all-weather balance. Autobild highlights exemplary aquaplaning resistance (longitudinal and lateral), very good wet and dry braking, precise handling and sporty, direct steering response. The SF3 is described as a “convincing all-rounder” with dynamic handling across conditions.


• Weaknesses: test reports list almost no critical faults — Autobild’s summary calls it a sovereign all-season tyre. There are no major negatives flagged in the supplied summaries.


• Use case: ideal for drivers seeking a top-performing all-season tyre with strong wet, dry and snow credentials — a clear choice if performance and safety in varied conditions are priorities.

Head-to-head and verdict
Across the same test suites the Pirelli consistently outperforms the Toyo — higher podium positions, far stronger wet and aquaplaning scores, and better snow handling. If you compare mutual test positions only, the SF3 is almost always above the Celsius AS2. Our numerical ratings reflect that gap (94% vs 54%).

Conclusion: choose the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 for best overall safety and balanced performance in all weather. The Toyo Celsius AS2 remains an economical, comfortable option for less demanding climates but is outmatched in wet, aquaplaning and comprehensive winter testing. For more manufacturer details visit the Pirelli brand page (Pirelli) or Toyo’s range page (Toyo).