Comparison: Toyo Celsius AS2 vs. Continental AllSeasonContact

Our tyre test comparison focuses on the Toyo Celsius AS2 and the Continental AllSeasonContact, which are among the top tyre models from manufacturers Toyo and Continental, respectively.

Made in Japan, the Toyo Celsius AS2 allround tyre has an overall rating of 54%. It shines in its resistance to aquaplaning and provides comfortable handling. In the Autobild 2022 test, it was praised for its high mileage and good price-performance ratio, with commendation for its aquaplaning reserves. However, it showed room for improvement with regards to its handling and response on wet roads, along with extended braking distance on the same. In the 2023 ace tests, it was credited for its stable dry handling and short braking distances on snow. Its weak point though was its satisfactory winter qualities and understeer on snowy/wet handling, coupled with elongated wet braking distances. In side-by-side rankings, the Toyo showed middle-of-the-pack performance with a 9th place from 11 in Autobild.

On the other hand, the Continental AllSeasonContact tyre, made in Slovakia, Czech Republic, and France, holds a higher overall rating at 77%. It reveals excellent winter qualities and secure handling on wet roads. Its top features include the likes of wet circle cornering, snow braking and handling, with aquaplaning-cross landing respectably high on the list. However, it showed room for improvement in dry conditions and aquaplaning qualities as per the Autobild 2024 summary. According to the Autobild 2022 comparison, it struggled with understeer and extended braking on dry roads and had limited wear and cost-efficiency. Yet, its exemplary winter qualities and stable wet handling were again highlighted by the same test. The AllSeasonContact performed better in the mutual tests, landing toward the trophy side in the Autobild ranking with a 3rd place of 11.

Verdict: The Continental AllSeasonContact outperforms the Toyo Celsius AS2 in overall ratings and tests. The Continental tyre excels in handling wet and snowy conditions, making it the perfect choice for drivers mainly concerned with safety in these conditions. Meanwhile, the Toyo Celsius AS2 excels in its resistance to aquaplaning and comfort, striking a balance between performance and cost-efficiency. Ultimately, the decision between these two depends on the driver's specific needs and usual driving conditions.