Comparison: Semperit Speed-Life 3 vs. Fulda EcoControl HP2 vs. Nokian WetProof vs. Petlas Imperium PT515

The Semperit Speed-Life 3 and Fulda EcoControl HP2 are both suitable summer tyres produced by established manufacturers Semperit and Fulda respectively.

The Semperit Speed-Life 3 is a successor to the Semperit Speed-Life. It is found to perform well in wet conditions, specifically in terms of wet braking. However, its performance on a dry surface and environmental performance are areas of improvement. Despite these shortcomings, it has an efficient fuel consumption, and satisfactory tread wear, factors which stand as their strengths.

Our test results have rated the Semperit Speed-Life 3 at 59%, placing it at a reputable position of 12 out of 53 tyres in the AutoBild test, and an impressive second place in the ADAC test out of 15 tyres. This demonstrates a significant improvement from its predecessor model.

On the other hand, we have the Fulda EcoControl HP2, an enhancement from the Fulda EcoControl HP. It grasps attention with its excellent external noise levels and exceptional performance in cross aquaplaning scenarios. While these features mark it out as a strong competitor, our tests detected some weaknesses in its performance on wet surfaces, which influences its overall score.

Despite this, the tyre shows impressive strength in its environmental performance and longevity. The Fulda EcoControl HP2 earns a rating of 71% on our tests. It ranks 20th among 53 tyres in the AutoBild test and secures an 8th spot in the 15-tyre ADAC test.

In conclusion, both these tyres have their distinct strengths and weaknesses. If wet surface performance and fuel efficiency are high on your priority list, then Semperit Speed-Life 3 is an ideal option. However, if you value quiet operation, excelling in cross aquaplaning, and environmental friendly credentials, then the Fulda EcoControl HP2 is a viable contender.

It’s important to note that these tests not only account for the individual features of the tyres but also consider the comprehensive performance over different scenarios, providing a holistic review for the most informed decision.