Comparison: Pirelli Cinturato All Season vs. Nokian WeatherProof

Today we are comparing two top tyres in the allround category: Pirelli Cinturato All Season and Nokian WeatherProof. These tyres are manufactured by Pirelli and Nokian respectively.

The Pirelli Cinturato All Season does not replace any previous models and currently does not have a succeeding model. This tyre's best feature, as reported by Autobild, is its dry handling. It secured 3rd position out of 9 total tyres in the Autobild test. However, this tyre showed slightly weaker performance in other tests, ranking 8th in both Autoklub ČR and Autozeitung, 5th in the ADAC test, and 9th in the ACE test. In the Autoexpress test, the tyre secured a 5th position, proving its moderate performance overall.

It's important to notice that in most tyre-tests where the Pirelli Cinturato All Season was tested, it achieved positions in the second half of the test field. The overall score for the Pirelli Cinturato All Season on our website is 19% which reflects this lower-half position in the tests.

On the other hand, the Nokian WeatherProof tyre, which is made in Finland and also does not replace any previous models, shows stronger test scores. It was awarded first position in the ACE and Autoexpress tests, with strong features in aquaplaning - cross, rolling resistance, snow braking, snow handling, and snow traction as reported by Autobild. It secured 6th, 2nd, 4th, and 3rd positions in the Autobild, Autoklub ČR, Autozeitung, and Gute-Fahrt tests respectively, all out of a total of up to 10 tyres. In the ADAC test, it achieved 3rd position out of 7 total tyres. With these higher rankings, the Nokian WeatherProof holds an esteemed position in multiple tyre-tests. Consequently, our overall rating for the Nokian WeatherProof tyre is 59%.

In conclusion, the strong test scores and the impressive performance across a variety of scenarios clearly make the Nokian WeatherProof the superior tyre compared to the Pirelli Cinturato All Season. Particularly in snowy conditions, the Nokian WeatherProof outclasses many competitors, making it an optimal tyre choice for allround driving scenarios in regions with varied and challenging weather conditions.