Comparison: Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 vs. Toyo Celsius AS2

This comparison looks at the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 (our score: 94%) versus the Toyo Celsius AS2 (our score: 54%) based on multiple tyre tests and reviews. For manufacturer details see Pirelli and Toyo. Neither model is listed as replaced by a newer generation at the time of these tests.

Across the Autobild test panels the SF3 consistently finished at the top: 1st place in an 11-tyre comparison and 2nd in a larger 37-tyre test. The Toyo Celsius AS2 placed near the lower third in the same comparisons (10th of 11 and 12th of 37). These positions reflect repeated strengths for the Pirelli and recurring compromises for the Toyo.

Summary of test data and performance

• Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3
  
  
  
  • Top-ranked in multiple Autobild tests (1st and 2nd).
  
  
  • Outstanding in dry braking, wet handling, aquaplaning resistance (longitudinal & cross), and snow traction/handling. Reviews highlight dynamic handling, direct steering response and exemplary aquaplaning behaviour.
  
  
  • Described as a balanced all-rounder with sportier handling and convincing performance in all conditions.
  
  
  
  


• Toyo Celsius AS2
  
  
  
  • Mid-to-low test positions (10th–12th) indicate weaker all-round competitiveness compared with the SF3.
  
  
  • Key strengths: comfort, low noise, price/value and fuel-efficient rolling resistance. Also praised for stable dry handling and long mileage.
  
  
  • Weaknesses reported: only satisfactory winter qualities, understeer in snow/wet handling and extended wet braking distances in some tests.
  
  
  
  

Test-wise comparison — who wins? The Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 is the clear winner in objective test results. It regularly finishes in the top positions and scores highly in critical safety areas such as wet braking and aquaplaning resistance, as well as in snow performance. The Toyo Celsius AS2 does not match the SF3 in mixed-condition safety metrics; its strengths lie in cost-efficiency, comfort and low rolling resistance rather than outright wet/winter grip.

Verdict — strengths & weaknesses

• Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3: Strengths — best-in-class wet and dry braking, excellent aquaplaning resistance and credible winter capability. Weaknesses — positioned and priced as a premium all-season performer (higher cost than budget alternatives).


• Toyo Celsius AS2: Strengths — value-oriented: low cost, high mileage potential, quiet and comfortable ride, good rolling resistance. Weaknesses — compromises in wet braking and winter handling; not as confident in mixed or adverse weather as the SF3.

Conclusion: If your priority is maximum safety and top all-weather performance in independent tests, the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 is the recommended choice. If you prioritise cost, comfort and long mileage and accept reduced wet/winter performance, the Toyo Celsius AS2 is a reasonable budget-oriented alternative.