Comparison: Michelin CrossClimate 2 vs. Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3

This head-to-head looks at two premium all-season tyres: the Michelin CrossClimate 2 and the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3. Both tyres score highly in independent tyre tests, but they target slightly different strengths. Neither model shows a listed replacement—both remain current in our dataset.

Test summary & mutual rankings

• Overall test ratings in our database: Michelin 92% vs Pirelli 95%.


• In multiple major comparative tests (AutoBild, Die Reifentester, AlVolante) the Pirelli most often finished ahead (1st or 2nd), while the Michelin typically placed 2nd–4th. This gives Pirelli the edge in overall podium positions across the sample of tests.


• Key test wins: Pirelli often tops wet and aquaplaning categories; Michelin consistently wins or ranks best on snow, rolling resistance and comfort/noise metrics.

Strengths — Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3
The SF3 is a standout in wet performance: multiple tests highlight best aquaplaning resistance (longitudinal & cross), top wet handling and braking, and strong dry handling/braking. Test notes describe it as “very well balanced across disciplines” and often the best performer on wet surfaces. Downsides reported: higher wear rates in some tests (reducing value per kilometre) and a relatively high purchase price. If you prioritise maximum wet-weather safety and fast response in dry driving, the Pirelli is the better overall test performer.

Strengths — Michelin CrossClimate 2
The CrossClimate 2 excels in winter behaviour and economy: top marks for snow traction, snow handling and snow braking, plus consistently low rolling resistance and very low noise. Tests praise its balanced all-round performance and fuel-saving potential. Weaknesses include slightly weaker aquaplaning behaviour and, in some wet-braking scenarios, longer stopping distances relative to the SF3. Several reviews also note a high purchase price combined with average wear, which can make cost per km less favourable.

Where each tyre shines (quick comparison)

• Wet & aquaplaning: Pirelli clearly superior in most tests.


• Dry handling & braking: Pirelli often leads, Michelin close behind.


• Snow & ice: Michelin is the more confident winter performer; Pirelli is very good but slightly behind Michelin in deep snow tests.


• Comfort & noise: Michelin typically offers quieter ride and better rolling resistance (fuel saving).


• Value & wear: Both are premium-priced; Pirelli shows higher wear in some tests, reducing long-term value.

Verdict
Overall test results place the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 slightly ahead as the best all-round performer—especially for drivers who prioritise wet-weather safety and dynamic handling. The Michelin CrossClimate 2 is the smarter choice for those who need superior snow performance, a quieter ride and lower rolling resistance for better fuel economy. For manufacturer information, see Pirelli and Michelin.