Comparison: Imperial EcoDriver 5 vs. Semperit Speed-Life 3

The need for safe and dependable tyres is paramount for any vehicle. Let's dive into a comparison between two summer tyres, the Imperial EcoDriver 5 and the Semperit Speed-Life 3.

The Imperial EcoDriver 5 is a summer tyre from Imperial, a reputable tyre manufacturer. The EcoDriver 5 carries our rating score of 17%. Unluckily, this tyre doesn't replace any previous models and there's no newer model replacing it. Clearly, Imperial is relying on this model to compete in the market for a while.

On the other hand, the Semperit Speed-Life 3 is the third model in the Speed-Life lineup which replaced the original Semperit Speed-Life. Produced by Semperit, the Speed-Life 3 is a summer tyre as well and boasts a higher rating of 59%.

Looking at the results from mutual tests, the positioning of these tyres paints a rather clear picture. In Autobild's test out of a total of 53 tyres, the Imperial EcoDriver 5 ranked 32nd while the Semperit Speed-Life 3 secured a more impressive 12th spot highlighting its wet braking as the best feature. In AUTO KLUB ČR's test, out of 19 tyres, the EcoDriver 5 ranked at 17th place, the Speed-Life 3 took the 10th spot. These results reflect the superior performance of the Semperit tyre in comparison to the Imperial one.

The strengths of the Imperial EcoDriver 5 seem to be overshadowed by its subpar test results, whereas the Semperit Speed-Life 3 has proved to deliver a good performance especially in wet conditions.

In conclusion, the Semperit Speed-Life 3 is a better choice in this comparison. This isn't to say the Imperial EcoDriver 5 is a poor tyre. However, its performance in these tests do not match that of the Semperit tyre. Worth noting, these tyres' performances could differ depending on driving conditions and personal preferences.

Both tyres are worthwhile considerations, with the final decision heavily dependent on individual needs and circumstances. It is advised to explore each tyre in detail to ensure the best fit.