Comparison: GoodYear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3 vs. Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 vs. Dunlop All Season 2

This direct comparison looks at the Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen‑3 and the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3, with one-sentence summaries of test results, aggregated strengths/weaknesses and an overall verdict. Manufacturer pages: Goodyear and Pirelli. Neither tyre is listed as replaced by a newer model in our data.

Quick numbers: our rating — Pirelli 95%, Goodyear 81%. Across multiple independent tests (Autobild, AUTOBILD, Aftonbladet, ALVOLANTE and others) the Pirelli consistently finished at or near the top, while the Goodyear is a solid all‑round performer with particular strengths on snow.

Test summary and comparison

Across the test matrix the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 repeatedly ranked better: numerous Autobild entries put the Pirelli in positions 1–2 (best marks for aquaplaning resistance, wet and dry braking, comfort and low noise). The Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen‑3 often sits mid‑to‑upper table (positions 3–6), praised for snow traction, predictable handling and economical rolling resistance but not matching the Pirelli’s level of wet/dry braking and aquaplaning performance.

• Pirelli strengths: exceptional aquaplaning resistance (longitudinal and cross), outstanding wet handling and braking, very good dry handling and ride comfort. AUTOBILD notes it as “very balanced” and the best candidate in wet conditions; Autobild quotes also underline dynamic handling and short wet braking distances.


• Goodyear strengths: excellent snow traction and cornering on snow, balanced all‑round behaviour, good wet handling in many tests and competitive rolling resistance. AUTOBILD highlights the Goodyear’s secure, sporty handling and short braking distances in mixed conditions.

Weaknesses

• Pirelli weaknesses: higher price is frequently mentioned; on deep snow it was described as slightly behind the best winter‑specialist competitors (e.g., Michelin in one Autobild note).


• Goodyear weaknesses: lower overall score reflects limitations in the very wet/dry extremes compared with Pirelli; some testers note only average mileage/km performance.

Which tyre is better in tests overall?

When comparing mutual test positions and aggregated ratings, the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 is the clear overall leader. It takes top positions in multiple Autobild and AUTOBILD rankings and shows best‑in‑class aquaplaning and wet braking performance. The Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen‑3 is a reliable, cost‑sensible all‑season choice and often the better pick for snowy conditions, but it trails the Pirelli in overall test podiums and in combined wet/dry safety metrics.

Verdict

Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 — recommended if your priority is the best possible all‑season performance in wet and mixed conditions, combined with high comfort and safety reserves; accept a higher purchase price for superior aquaplaning and braking. Score: 95%.
Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen‑3 — a very good, balanced all‑season tyre that stands out on snow and offers sensible pricing and efficiency; choose it if you need a confident winter performer without chasing the absolute top marks in wet/dry stopping and aquaplaning tests. Score: 81%.

Links: tyre pages — Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen‑3, Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3. Manufacturer pages — Goodyear, Pirelli.