Comparison: Continental AllSeasonContact 2 vs. Toyo Celsius AS2

Comparing the Continental AllSeasonContact 2 and the Toyo Celsius AS2 across multiple independent tests shows a clear performance gap. Our aggregated score for the Continental is 87% versus 54% for the Toyo, and test ranks consistently favour the Continental in wet, dry and winter disciplines. For manufacturer information see Continental and Toyo.

Overall test positions (selected):

• Autobild / 16 tyres: Continental positioned 2nd, Toyo 14th.


• AUTOBILD / 37 tyres: Continental 3rd, Toyo 12th.


• ACE / 9 tyres: Continental 1st, Toyo 9th.

Continental AllSeasonContact 2 — summary of strengths & weaknesses

• Strengths: Outstanding wet braking and wet handling, reliable snow traction, low exterior noise and good rolling resistance. Tests praise short braking distances on wet and snowy surfaces and strong dry handling — a true all-round performer with a dynamic feel.


• Weaknesses: Higher price point and in some reports only average aquaplaning reserves. A slight tendency to understeer was noted in sporty driving.


• Verdict: The Continental is the clear winner in mixed-condition testing — the best choice if you prioritise wet and winter safety, low noise and balanced performance across seasons.

Toyo Celsius AS2 — summary of strengths & weaknesses

• Strengths: Excellent value and high mileage — Toyo scores well for comfort, exterior noise and cost-effectiveness. Some tests highlight good aquaplaning reserves and very competitive kilometrage.


• Weaknesses: Consistently weaker in winter and wet performance: longer wet braking distances, reduced grip on snow and a tendency toward understeer on wet and snowy surfaces. Toyo’s overall handling in rain and snow falls significantly behind the Continental.


• Verdict: The Celsius AS2 is a budget-conscious, long-lasting choice for drivers in milder climates who primarily value comfort and wear. It is not recommended where strong wet braking or winter traction are priorities.

Head-to-head conclusion
Across the same test programs the Continental AllSeasonContact 2 consistently finished near the top (1st–3rd places in key comparative tests), while the Toyo Celsius AS2 tended to occupy lower positions (9th–14th). That pattern mirrors the numerical ratings (87% vs 54%) and the qualitative findings: Continental is the superior all-season tyre for balanced safety and performance; Toyo is better as a value / high-mileage alternative for less demanding conditions.

Neither model is reported as having been replaced by a newer generation at the time of these tests. For full test details and individual test reports see the tyre pages: Continental AllSeasonContact 2 and Toyo Celsius AS2.