Comparison: Kleber Quadraxer 3 vs. Toyo Celsius AS2 vs. Firestone Multiseason 2 vs. Michelin CrossClimate 2

Summary comparison: The Kleber Quadraxer 3 (product page) outperforms the Toyo Celsius AS2 (product page) across the majority of independent tests. Kleber scores a high 83% in our rating and regularly places in the top third of comparative tests (positions 4 and 7 in Autobild test runs), while Toyo sits at 54% and typically ranks lower (around position 12).

What the tests say — aggregated highlights

• Kleber Quadraxer 3 — praised repeatedly for snow traction and handling, short dry braking distances, reliable aquaplaning resistance (especially longitudinal), and a comfortable ride. Test notes consistently show it as a strong winter performer and a safe choice for mixed conditions. Recurring weaknesses: a tendency to understeer on wet or dry surfaces and slightly delayed steering feedback in some scenarios.


• Toyo Celsius AS2 — stands out for comfort, low rolling resistance and value for money. Test reports emphasize good aquaplaning reserves and high mileage (long wear). However, winter performance is only rated as average: testers note understeer on wet/snowy roads, longer wet braking distances and somewhat delayed steering response in demanding conditions.

Mutual test positions and direct comparison
Across Autobild and TyreReviews summaries, Kleber consistently finishes higher than Toyo. In head-to-head attributes: Kleber usually wins for snow braking, snow cornering and aquaplaning resistance, while Toyo competes on comfort, exterior noise and price/value. If you prioritise winter safety and all-round grip, Kleber takes the lead; if budget, longevity and fuel efficiency are your priority, Toyo is attractive.

Strengths & Weaknesses — quick verdicts

• Kleber Quadraxer 3 — Strengths: excellent snow performance, strong aquaplaning behaviour, short dry braking and good comfort. Weaknesses: understeer tendency on wet/dry, slightly muted steering feel. Overall verdict: best all-round winter-oriented choice among the two.


• Toyo Celsius AS2 — Strengths: strong value proposition, good aquaplaning reserves, long wear and low rolling resistance. Weaknesses: only satisfactory winter qualities, longer wet braking distances and understeer in slippery situations. Overall verdict: cost-effective, long-lasting tyre that compromises winter handling for economy.

Model continuity and replacement
Neither tested tyre is reported as replaced in the dataset. Kleber Quadraxer 3 followed the Quadraxer 2 in the model line (previous model), while Toyo Celsius AS2 has no listed predecessor in these results.

Recommendation
If your driving includes regular winter conditions, snow and mixed wet roads, choose the Kleber Quadraxer 3 for overall safety and balanced performance. If you prioritise mileage, low rolling resistance and the best price-to-performance ratio for mostly mild winters, the Toyo Celsius AS2 is a pragmatic pick.

Manufacturer pages: Kleber (manufacturer) — part of the premium group behind the Quadraxer family; Toyo (manufacturer) — the official Toyo all-round tyres overview.