Comparison: GoodYear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 vs. Nokian Powerproof vs. Kumho Ecsta Sport (PS72)

In this text, we will compare two highly-rated summer tyres - the GoodYear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 and the Nokian Powerproof. Both tyres come from well-known manufacturers, GoodYear and Nokian, and are designed to provide excellent performance on various surfaces.

The GoodYear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 is a successor to the popular Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 and has been replaced by the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 6. Our rating for this tyre is 94%, meaning it is one of the top choices for summer tyres. This tyre is mostly produced in Slovenia and Germany.

On the other hand, the Nokian Powerproof is a Finnish-made tyre with an 85% rating, demonstrating a strong performance as a summer tyre. Unlike the GoodYear model, there is no newer tyre that has replaced it.

In various tests conducted by leading auto magazines, the GoodYear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 consistently ranked higher than the Nokian Powerproof. Here is a summary of their positions in mutual tests:

• Autozeitung: GoodYear (1st place, 10 tyres tested) | Nokian (6th place)


• AutoMotorSport: GoodYear (1st place, 11 tyres tested) | Nokian (7th place)


• Autobild: GoodYear (2nd place, 11 tyres tested) | Nokian (7th place)


• ADAC: GoodYear (3rd place, 16 tyres tested) | Nokian (11th place)


• Gute-Fahrt: GoodYear (2nd place, 10 tyres tested) | Nokian (4th place)


• Autobild (2nd test): GoodYear (1st place, 10 tyres tested) | Nokian (4th place)

Highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each tyre:

GoodYear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5:

• Strengths: Excellent aquaplaning resistance, wet braking performance, dry braking, dry steering response, exterior noise, comfort, wet handling, price-value, mileage, grass traction, and wet circle cornering.


• Weaknesses: No specific weaknesses were reported in the tests.

Nokian Powerproof:

• Strengths: Wet braking, noise, interior noise, handling on gravel, and wet handling.


• Weaknesses: Lower overall ranking in tests, indicating weaker performance in some areas compared to the GoodYear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5.

In conclusion, based on test results and expert opinions, the GoodYear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 outperforms the Nokian Powerproof in most categories and across different tests. With its higher overall rating of 94% and consistently higher rankings in mutual tests, the GoodYear tyre is an excellent choice for a summer tyre that provides outstanding performance in various conditions.