Comparison: Vredestein ULTRAC vs. Fulda EcoControl HP2 vs. Kumho Ecsta HS52

In this summary, we are comparing two summer tyres: Vredestein ULTRAC manufactured in Hungary and the Fulda EcoControl HP2. Notably, the latter is successor of the previous Fulda EcoControl HP model.

The Vredestein ULTRAC, which has been dormant equipment for the BMW 2-series Active Tourer, gets a lower rating of 21%. However, the tyre seems to excel in both wet and dry conditions according to test results from Autobild and ADAC. Among its strongest features, wet handling, dry handling, and aquaplaning stand out. Despite these high-performance capabilities, it's worth noting the model falls short in terms of fuel consumption and tyre wear.

On the other hand, the Fulda EcoControl HP2 performs better in our rating, reaching up to 69%. According to Autobild's testing, it exhibits significantly low exterior noise, a factor that contributes to a peaceful drive. Furthermore, the tyre demonstrates exemplary performance in terms of dry braking and durability. On the downside, the Fulda model shows some weaknesses in lateral support on dry roads.

In terms of competition, the Vredestein tyre performs relatively well, landing the 3rd position out of 55 tyres in the Autobild test. Conversely, in the same test, the Fulda tyre came in at the 16th position. When compared by ADAC, the results are closer together, with the Vredestein tyre placed at no. 13 and the Fulda in 14th position out of 16 tyres.

Overall, these tyres have their strengths and weaknesses based on diverse testing situations. The Vredestein ULTRAC is notable for its excellent driving dynamics and performance in both dry and wet conditions but has a lower lifespan and high rolling resistance. The Fulda EcoControl HP2 is a solid performing and economical tyre with exceptional ride comfort, but struggles with lateral support on dry roads.

Considering these insights, it's clear that the preferable tyre, between the Vredestein and Fulda models, hinges on the drivers' preferences of handling, comfort, noise, and longevity factors.