Comparison: Gt Radial Fe2 vs. Vredestein ULTRAC vs. GoodYear Efficientgrip Performance 2 vs. Michelin Primacy 5

GT Radial FE2 vs Vredestein Ultrac – two popular summer choices with different priorities. This comparison pulls together the latest independent test data to help you decide which tyre fits your needs for safety, efficiency, and value.

Tyre overview

• GT Radial FE2 (UHP): prioritises balance and efficiency. Manufacturer: GT Radial.


• Vredestein Ultrac (summer): focuses on dynamic performance and wet safety. Made in HU; OE fitment for BMW 2‑series Active Tourer. Manufacturer: Vredestein.

Head-to-head in independent tests

• Autobild (55 tyres): Vredestein Ultrac P3 vs GT Radial FE2 P19. The Ultrac consistently excelled in wet handling, wet circle, dry handling, and both longitudinal and lateral aquaplaning, while the FE2 landed mid‑pack overall.


• Autobild 2024 qualitative notes:
  
  
  
  • GT Radial FE2: Pros – good wet and dry handling with a pleasing balance; low rolling resistance. Cons – extended wet braking; average aquaplaning resistance.
  
  
  • Vredestein Ultrac: Pros – excellent dynamics, short wet and dry braking, very good aquaplaning safety. Cons – lower projected mileage; elevated rolling resistance.
  
  
  
  


• TyreReviews.com 2023: Ultrac again highlighted for excellent wet handling and the best aquaplaning resistance on test, with good dry braking; trade‑offs include high rolling resistance and higher external noise.

What the data says
If you prioritise wet‑road safety and dynamic grip, the Vredestein Ultrac is the stronger performer across multiple categories and tests, regularly scoring near the top for wet handling, braking, and aquaplaning. Its main compromises are efficiency (rolling resistance), potential wear/longevity, and noise.
The GT Radial FE2 impresses with a balanced feel and low rolling resistance—useful for fuel economy—and delivers competent dry and wet handling. However, it loses ground in critical safety metrics like wet braking distance and aquaplaning resistance, which explains its mid‑field overall placement against a large field.

Verdict: which tyre is better overall?
Based on mutual test results, the Vredestein Ultrac is the overall winner, particularly for drivers who encounter frequent rain or value strong braking and confidence at the limit. Choose the GT Radial FE2 if your priorities lean toward efficiency and balanced everyday manners at a likely lower price point, and you’re willing to trade some wet‑safety headroom.

Model lifecycle: Neither tyre is listed as replaced by a newer model at this time.