Comparison: Firestone Multiseason 2 vs. Fulda MultiControl vs. Michelin ALPIN 6 vs. GoodYear UltraGrip Performance 3

This head-to-head compares the Firestone Multiseason 2 and the Fulda MultiControl across multiple Autobild test programs and our internal ratings. Both tyres serve different segments (Firestone listed as a winter tyre, Fulda as an allround), but side-by-side results show a clear performance gap.

Quick facts: Firestone Multiseason 2 — made in IT, our rating 56%. Fulda MultiControl — our rating 3%. Neither model in the supplied data shows a newer replacement model (no replacement link provided).

Test summary and ranking

• In Autobild comparative tests the Firestone finished notably higher: a top result of 6th place out of 32 in one test and 22nd of 37 in another. Test reports highlight its strengths on rolling resistance, snow traction and value for money.


• The Fulda appeared near the rear of the same test lists (26th/32 and 27th/37), indicating consistent weakness relative to competitors in those test fields.


• Autobild text summaries for the Firestone (2020 and 2023 extracts) repeatedly praise short snow and wet braking, good mileage and low rolling resistance, while noting only moderate aquaplaning safety reserves and somewhat compromised dry cornering safety margins.

Firestone Multiseason 2 — strengths & weaknesses
Strengths: Strong snow traction and short braking distances on snow, low rolling resistance (good for economy), very competitive price/performance and high mileage results reported. In multiple Autobild tests the tyre ranks in the upper half of the field, reflecting consistent competence in winter-related tasks.
Weaknesses: Test notes point to moderate side grip on snow and limited safety reserves in curve aquaplaning. Dry braking and high-speed cornering safety margins are not class-leading, so drivers who prioritize sharp dry handling should compare premium options.

Fulda MultiControl — strengths & weaknesses
Strengths: The available data does not list clear performance advantages for the Fulda in these tests. It is positioned as an allround option but did not translate into competitive rankings in the referenced Autobild comparisons.
Weaknesses: Very poor overall performance in the compiled tests — finishing in the lower ranks (26th and 27th), and an extremely low internal rating (3%). These results suggest significant shortcomings in key safety or performance areas compared with peer tyres.

Head-to-head verdict: Across the supplied tests and summaries the Firestone Multiseason 2 is the clear winner: it delivers reliable winter performance, lower rolling resistance and much stronger test placements. The Fulda MultiControl underperforms in the same test fields and receives a very low overall rating, making it difficult to recommend based on these results.

For brand and product pages: Firestone manufacturer — /firestone/, tyre page — /firestone-multiseason-2. Fulda manufacturer — /fulda/allround/, tyre page — /fulda-multicontrol.