Comparison: Continental ContiPremiumContact 5 vs. Semperit Speed-Life 2 vs. Fulda EcoControl HP

The comparison below focuses on two popular summer tyres: the Continental ContiPremiumContact 5 and the Semperit Speed‑Life 2. Both appear in major European tyre tests, but results are mixed: each tyre scores better in different test programs, so the best choice depends on what you prioritize.

Test summary (positions)

• ADAC (16 tyres): Continental ContiPremiumContact 5 finished 3rd, Semperit Speed‑Life 2 finished 6th.


• AutoBild (50 tyres): Semperit Speed‑Life 2 finished 3rd, Continental ContiPremiumContact 5 finished 9th.

These placements show a clear pattern of mixed strengths. Continental takes the lead in ADAC’s comparative ranking, suggesting a very balanced performance in the areas ADAC values most. Conversely, Semperit achieves a top‑3 AutoBild result, indicating exceptional standing in that magazine’s evaluation criteria.

What the test positions tell you (strengths & weaknesses)

• Continental ContiPremiumContact 5 — Strengths: a high ADAC placing (3rd of 16) points to reliable, well‑balanced behaviour across typical safety and comfort metrics. Weaknesses: a lower AutoBild ranking (9th of 50) suggests it may be slightly outperformed by rivals on some metrics where AutoBild places emphasis (for example, outright dry lap times or cost/value tradeoffs), even though it remains a strong all‑round tyre. The model is manufactured in the Czech Republic (madeIn: CZ).


• Semperit Speed‑Life 2 — Strengths: very strong AutoBild result (3rd of 50) implies standout qualities in the test criteria used there. Weaknesses: a lower ADAC finish (6th of 16) shows it isn’t universally dominant and may be less convincing in some ADAC assessment areas compared with the Continental. Semperit’s positioning suggests excellent value‑for‑money or targeted performance attributes that AutoBild rewards.

Head‑to‑head conclusion
Neither tyre is an outright winner across both tests — results are split. If you value the ADAC ranking and what it typically represents (a broad mix of safety, wet performance and everyday balance), the ContiPremiumContact 5 holds an edge. If you prioritise the attributes AutoBild emphasises (where the Speed‑Life 2 placed in the top three), then Semperit may be the better pick. In practical terms: Continental = balanced performer; Semperit = strong contender in AutoBild’s criteria.

Model lifecycle / replacements
Both models have since been succeeded by newer generations. The ContiPremiumContact 5 has been replaced by the Continental PremiumContact 6, and the Semperit Speed‑Life 2 has been superseded by the Semperit Speed‑Life 3. If you’re researching current tyre options, consider the successor models for updated compounds and improved test performance.

For manufacturer information see: Continental and Semperit. Overall, both tyres remain competitive — choose based on which test authority and performance characteristics matter most to your driving needs.