Comparison: BFGoodrich Advantage vs. Nokian WetProof vs. Kumho Ecsta PS71

If you are stuck choosing between the BFGoodrich Advantage tyre and the Nokian WetProof tyre, we are here to help you make an informed decision by comparing their overall test results and strengths/weaknesses. The BFGoodrich Advantage has an 80% overall rating, while the Nokian WetProof has a slightly better score with 87%.

First, let’s examine the BFGoodrich Advantage tyre. According to test results, this tyre performed better in fuel efficiency in the ADAC test, with a 9th position out of 15. It also showcased strong dry handling and dry handling in the Autobild test, ranking 18th out of 53 tyres tested. However, the BFGoodrich Advantage our rating did not rank as high in other tests, such as Autozeitung, GTÜ, and Firmenauto.

On the other hand, the Finnish-made Nokian WetProof tyre demonstrated a better overall performance in the tests. It ranked higher in noise and wet circle cornering in the ADAC test, with a 11th position out of 15 tyres. The WetProof also showed exceptionally good results in GTÜ and Firmenauto tests, placing 2nd in both with top features like wet circle cornering, wet handling, wet handling (objective), wet side guide, and exterior noise. It even ranked 6th in Autozeitung and AutoBild tests.

A summary of Nokian WetProof's strengths (autumn 2017) include its effectiveness, balanced performance, and good wet and dry traction. The tyre's weaknesses lie in its environmental balance, wear life, abrasion, and sustainability.

In conclusion, our verdict for both tyre's overall strengths and weaknesses are as follows:

• BFGoodrich Advantage


• Strengths: Fuel Efficiency, Dry Handling


• Weaknesses: Overall medioćre test results compared to Nokian WetProof

• Nokian WetProof


• Strengths: Noise, Wet Circle Cornering, Wet Handling, Exterior Noise


• Weaknesses: Environmental Balance, Wear Life, Abrasion, Sustainability

When choosing between the BFGoodrich Advantage and the Nokian WetProof tyres, the WetProof appears to be better overall, ranking higher in most categories with slightly better ratings. However, it is crucial to consider specific tests relevant to your driving needs when making a decision.