Comparison: Toyo Proxes Comfort vs. Semperit Speed-Life 3 vs. Michelin Primacy 5 vs. GoodYear Efficientgrip Performance 2

The Toyo Proxes Comfort and the Semperit Speed-Life 3 are both summer tyres, with Toyo made in Japan and Semperit originating from an unknown location. Across the board, the Toyo tyre outperforms the Semperit tyre in tests with a rating of 74% vs 47%. While both tyres are suitable for summer conditions, the Toyo tyre stands out in the touring category. Despite no previous models or newer tyres replacing these models, each tyre has distinct strengths and weaknesses observed in various tests.

The Autobild 2025 test indicates the Toyo Proxes Comfort tyre's strengths include its resistance to Aquaplaning, short stopping distances, and impressive performance in the dry. The downsides, as per Autobild 2024, are its modest longevity and noise level. Despite placing 17th out of 53 in the Autobild test, the tyre managed a strong 5th out of 18 on the ADAC test.

The Semperit Speed-Life 3 tyre, whereas, demonstrated strengths in wet braking, ranking 12th out of 53 in the Autobild test. However, it fared poorly in the ADAC test with a position of 16 out of 18. Balancing this strong wet performance, Autobild 2024 highlighted its efficiency and reasonable lifespan but noted its underperformance on dry roads. Moreover, criticisms were also leveled at its environmental impact.

To conclude, while each tyre has its distinct advantages, the Toyo Proxes Comfort tyre emerges as a superior choice overall due to its balanced handling and performance in wet and dry conditions. For more information on manufacturer details follow Toyo and Semperit.