Comparison: Toyo Proxes Comfort vs. Debica Presto HP2 vs. Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2

If you're looking for a reliable summer tyre, two options you might consider are the Toyo Proxes Comfort and the Debica Presto HP2. Both of these tyres have their own strengths and weaknesses, but how do they compare against each other in tests? Let's delve into the details and find out.

Toyo Proxes Comfort

The Toyo Proxes Comfort tyre, made in Japan, is a touring summer tyre that has received an overall rating of 74% from us. It is particularly known for its dry handling, as rated by Autobild in their test where it got 17th position out of 53 tested tyres. Dynamisches Nass- und Trockenhandling, kurze Bremswege, and a leises Abrollgeräusch are among its main positives, whereas a Geringe Laufleistung was listed as the downside.

However, in the ADAC test, this Toyo tyre ranked very well, finishing 5th out of 18 tyres tested. No newer version has replaced the Toyo Proxes Comfort, meaning that it has proven to be a reliable model throughout its lifespan.

Debica Presto HP2

On the other hand, the Debica Presto HP2 has an overall rating of 70% in our books. Its strengths lie in its Price/value ratio, as rated by Autobild in their test where it acquired 16th position out of 53 tyres, slightly better than its Toyo counterpart. The HP2's strengths include gute Umweltbilanz, gut bei Laufleistung, Abrieb und Effizienz, while nicht ganz ausgewogen and Schwächen bei der Fahrsicherheit (Abwertung) are listed as the weaknesses.

In the ADAC test, this Debica tyre managed to secure the 7th position out of 18 tyres. Despite the weaknesses, no new version of this model has been introduced so far, making it a consistent choice in the brand's range.

Conclusion

Overall, both the Toyo Proxes Comfort and Debica Presto HP2 are solid choices for summer tyres. While the Toyo excels in handling, particularly in dry conditions, the Debica offers excellent value for the price. Given that the Toyo Proxes Comfort has a higher overall rating and performed better in the ADAC test, it might be a safer choice for those prioritising performance. However, if cost-effectiveness is a major consideration for you, the Debica might be a more suitable pick due to its better price/value ratio.

Remember, the right tyre for you will depend on your specific requirements, driving style and budget. Always refer to independent tests and reviews to make an informed decision.