This head-to-head compares the Toyo Celsius AS2 and the Continental AllSeasonContact 2 across independent tyre tests and our lab ratings. The two all-season tyres serve similar markets, but test results show a clear performance gap: the Continental AllSeasonContact 2 scores much higher overall (our rating 87%) than the Toyo Celsius AS2 (our rating 54%).
Quick links
Read full specs:
Toyo Celsius AS2 — maker:
Toyo.
Full details:
Continental AllSeasonContact 2 — maker:
Continental.
Toyo Celsius AS2 — summary of test data and verdict
The Toyo Celsius AS2 positions in comparative tests are consistently low:
14th of 16 (AutoBild),
12th of 37 (AUTOBILD large test) and
9th of 9 (ACE). Test notes highlight its main advantages as
comfort, low exterior noise and good mileage/value, plus decent aquaplaning reserves in some test reports.
- Strengths: comfortable ride, quiet running, long wear / high mileage, attractive price/value.
- Weaknesses: weak wet grip and extended wet braking distances, limited snow performance and a tendency to understeer in wet/snow conditions. Overall low placings across headline tests indicate compromised all-season balance.
Verdict: the Celsius AS2 is a budget-friendly, long-lasting choice for drivers prioritising comfort and mileage in mild climates, but it is not recommended where strong wet or winter braking and handling are required.
Continental AllSeasonContact 2 — summary of test data and verdict
The Continental AllSeasonContact 2 is a class leader in recent tests:
2nd of 16 and
3rd of 37 in AutoBild runs and
1st of 9 in ACE. Test highlights repeatedly praise
wet handling, wet braking, snow traction, low exterior noise and good rolling resistance. Review notes call it an “all-rounder” with convincing dynamic behaviour across dry, wet and snowy surfaces.
- Strengths: excellent wet and snowy performance (short braking distances, confident handling), refined NVH (low road noise), good rolling resistance and overall driving dynamics.
- Weaknesses: higher price point and a slight tendency to understeer reported in some dynamic tests; aquaplaning reserves described as average in one report.
Verdict: the Continental is the stronger, more balanced all-season tyre for mixed conditions and drivers seeking top wet/snow safety and dynamic behaviour, justifying its premium positioning.
Head-to-head conclusion
Across mutual tests the Continental clearly outperforms the Toyo: consistently higher test positions and frequent praise for wet and winter performance make the
Continental AllSeasonContact 2 the better choice overall for safety and dynamic control. The Toyo Celsius AS2 remains an attractive option only where comfort, noise and long tread life at a low purchase price are the dominant priorities, and where severe wet and winter demands are uncommon.
Note: neither model is listed as having been replaced by a newer version in our database.
