Comparison: Toyo Celsius AS2 vs. Bridgestone Weather Control A005 EVO vs. Vredestein Quatrac Pro

Here, we compare two high-quality, all-round tyres: Toyo Celsius AS2 and Bridgestone Weather Control A005 EVO. Produced respectively by two of the industry's leading manufacturers, Toyo Tires from Japan and Bridgestone with facilities in Hungary and Italy, these tyres have each been allocated an overall rating by our experts, with the Toyo scoring 54% and the Bridgestone leading with 61%.

In terms of test performance, the Toyo Celsius AS2 secured a ranking of 9th place in Autobild's comparison of 11 tyres. This particular tyre is appraised for its superior aquaplaning capabilities both in a straight line and lateral motion. It is also highly commended for its comfort and rolling resistance. Despite its high mileage, cost-effectiveness, and impressive aquaplaning reserves, it faces criticism for its slightly delayed steering response and longer wet-braking distance on wet surfaces. However, this tyre has not yet been replaced by a newer model.

In contrast, the Bridgestone Weather Control A005 EVO received a higher ranking of the 8th place. Detailed for its excellent grip and braking on wet roads, and efficient snow braking, its prowess extends to features such as dry handling and rolling resistance. With an affinity for dry conditions, offering precise handling and short dry-braking distances, the tyre was slighted for its average steering precision and understeering behaviour on snowy and wet terrains. Like the Toyo, there is currently no new model to supersede the A005 EVO.

In summary, both the Toyo Celsius AS2 and Bridgestone Weather Control A005 EVO have unique strengths, with the former excelling in aquaplaning and comfort, and the latter being adept in varying weather conditions. Prospective buyers are thus advised to consider their driving requirements and conditions before making an informed decision. While our experts have rated the Bridgestone higher overall, the choice between the two ultimately depends on individual needs and preferences.