Comparison: Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde vs. Maxxis Premitra HP5 vs. Michelin Primacy 5 vs. GoodYear Efficientgrip Performance 2

We present a comprehensive comparison between the Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde and the Maxxis Premitra HP5. Both these tyres are rated equally at 56%.

Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde

The Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde is a summer tyre with impressive performance in the tests. It secured 10th position out of 11 in Firmenauto's tests. However, in AutoBild's testing, it starred by achieving the 4th position out of 51 tested tyres. Its best performance was evident in ADAC's tests, where it led the competition by bagging the 1st position among 16 tyres.

Verdict: The strengths of the Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde lie in its high-ranking performance in competitive tests. However, it lacks a little in competitive positioning when compared to other tyres under the same conditions. No new model has replaced this tyre as yet.

Maxxis Premitra HP5

On the other hand, the Maxxis Premitra HP5 also presented quite a show in the tests. This summer tyre stood at 6th position out of 11 in the Firmenauto's test, with its best features being its wet handling and exterior noise. When tested by AutoBild, it secured a respectable 9th position out of 51. However, the tyre performed less admirably in the wet braking category in ADAC's test, taking the 15th spot out of 16 tyres.

Verdict: The Maxxis Premitra HP5 shines in situations that involve wet handling and provides a quiet experience thanks to its low exterior noise. Its main weakness lies in wet braking, as evidenced by its performance in ADAC's test. Currently, no newer model has replaced this tyre.

Concluding Thoughts

Comparatively, although both tyres are rated at 56%, the overall performance of the Pirelli P1 Cinturato Verde showcases more consistency across different tests. However, the Maxxis Premitra HP5 offers excellent handling in wet conditions and is fair competition. As in any choice of tyre, your decision would need to consider your preferred driving conditions and the strengths of each tyre within those conditions.