Comparison: Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 vs. Continental AllSeasonContact 2 vs. Vredestein Quatrac

When comparing the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 (our score: 94%) and the Continental AllSeasonContact 2 (our score: 88%), the test evidence points to two very capable all‑season tyres with different emphases. Neither model has been replaced by a newer generation at the time of these tests.

Test positions and overall picture: Across major test houses Pirelli consistently finishes at or near the top — 1st in Autoexpress, 1st in Alvolante, and podium places in several AUTOBILD runs — while Continental typically ranks slightly lower (2nd in Autoexpress, 3rd–7th range in AUTOBILD/Autobild). Combining the published results, Pirelli tends to come out ahead overall for wet and dry safety margins, while Continental shows its strengths in snow, ice and long‑term economy.

Where Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 excels

• Wet performance & aquaplaning resistance: Multiple tests highlight Pirelli as the best candidate in wet conditions and the leader in aquaplaning (longitudinal & cross) — a clear safety advantage in heavy rain.


• Dry braking & handling: Short braking distances and strong dry lap performance make it a confident choice for mixed driving.


• Comfort and noise: Test reports repeatedly note low exterior noise and good ride comfort.

Where Continental AllSeasonContact 2 excels

• Snow and ice traction: Continental is frequently praised for snow braking, snow handling and ice performance — making it a top pick for winter‑prone regions.


• Rolling resistance and wear: Low rolling resistance and very good wear results were highlighted, translating to better fuel economy and long‑term value.


• Comfort & wet handling: Test summaries note direct steering, quietness and excellent wet handling in many scenarios.

Head‑to‑head verdict: If you prioritise the strongest wet‑weather safety, aquaplaning resistance and top dry braking performance, the Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF3 is the overall test winner. For buyers focused on winter grip, lowest rolling resistance, longest wear and best value over time, the Continental AllSeasonContact 2 is the smarter choice.

For manufacturer details, visit the brands: Pirelli and Continental. In short: Pirelli = top wet/dry safety and handling; Continental = superior winter performance, efficiency and value. Choose based on which strengths matter most for your typical driving conditions.