18 Shops · 56,847+ Products

Comparison: Maxxis Premitra HP5 vs. BFGoodrich Advantage vs. Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2 vs. Toyo Proxes Comfort

4 mutual test(s) with detailed data

If you're in search for high-quality summer tyres, it's worth considering Maxxis Premitra HP5 and BFGoodrich Advantage. Both of these models have their own strengths and weaknesses as per user and professional test results.


Maxxis Premitra HP5


The Maxxis brand was found in numerous tests to have launched a competitive product in the form of the Premitra HP5 tyre. The tyre has an overall rating of 78%, showcasing good performance. Across several tests, these tyres demonstrated excellent aquaplaning resistance and wet handling performance, ranking 9th out of 53 on AutoBild and 4th out of 9 on GTÜ. The Maxxis Premitra HP5 also scored well in terms of dry handling and grip level on both, wet and dry surfaces.


Various test feedback point towards good kilometre performance and short dry braking distances as significant plusses. A point of attention, however, might be the slightly delayed steering response.


BFGoodrich Advantage


On the other hand, the BFGoodrich Advantage performed admirably well with an overall rating of 76%. This tyre was highly praised for its comfort, dry handling and fuel efficiency. It ranked 18th out of 53 on AutoBild and stood out in the test from ADAC, gaining high marks for its fuel efficiency.


Feedback from tests highlight the dynamic and silent drive the Advantage offers, along with the stable drive behaviour and short braking distances on dry surfaces. A minor drawback to account for might be its understeering tendency on wet surfaces.


Verdict


In mutual test positions, it can be observed that the Maxxis Premitra HP5 generally ranks higher, especially in resistance to aquaplaning and wet handling. However, the BFGoodrich Advantage holds its own with a more fuel-efficient performance.


In conclusion, both these tyres offer quality performance and can be chosen based on your preferences. The Maxxis Premitra HP5 is an excellent choice for individuals seeking excellent aquaplaning resistance and wet handling, while the BFGoodrich Advantage stands out for those wanting a comfortable, quiet, and fuel efficient driving experience, especially in dry conditions.

Test Profile

Maxxis
Premitra HP5
BFGoodrich
Advantage
Goodyear
Efficient Grip Performance 2
Toyo
Proxes Comfort
Number of tests
31
14
18
16
Best position
#1
#8
#1
#5
Average position
9.5
13.4
6.1
9.7
Latest test
2024
2026
2024
2025
Available sizes
64
153
47
116

Performance comparison

Averaged from 4 tests

Wet Performance
Maxxis Premitra HP5
71%
Maxxis
Premitra HP5
BFGoodrich Advantage
62%
BFGoodrich
Advantage
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
75%
Goodyear
Efficient Grip Performance 2
Toyo Proxes Comfort
63%
Toyo
Proxes Comfort
Wet Braking
Maxxis Premitra HP5
68%
BFGoodrich Advantage
69%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
66%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
57%
Wet Handling
Maxxis Premitra HP5
66%
BFGoodrich Advantage
56%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
71%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
66%
Wet Circle Cornering
Maxxis Premitra HP5
61%
BFGoodrich Advantage
61%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
88%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
78%
Aquaplaning Longitudinal
Maxxis Premitra HP5
74%
BFGoodrich Advantage
62%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
63%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
56%
Aquaplaning Cross
Maxxis Premitra HP5
85%
BFGoodrich Advantage
63%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
85%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
57%
Dry Performance
Maxxis Premitra HP5
69%
Maxxis
Premitra HP5
BFGoodrich Advantage
76%
BFGoodrich
Advantage
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
79%
Goodyear
Efficient Grip Performance 2
Toyo Proxes Comfort
61%
Toyo
Proxes Comfort
Dry Braking
Maxxis Premitra HP5
73%
BFGoodrich Advantage
67%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
65%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
74%
Dry Handling
Maxxis Premitra HP5
67%
BFGoodrich Advantage
79%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
78%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
83%
Dry Lane Change
Maxxis Premitra HP5
62%
BFGoodrich Advantage
81%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
81%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
43%
Dry Steering Reaction
Maxxis Premitra HP5
75%
BFGoodrich Advantage
75%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
92%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
42%
Comfort & Noise
Maxxis Premitra HP5
70%
Maxxis
Premitra HP5
BFGoodrich Advantage
71%
BFGoodrich
Advantage
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
78%
Goodyear
Efficient Grip Performance 2
Toyo Proxes Comfort
66%
Toyo
Proxes Comfort
Noise Exterior
Maxxis Premitra HP5
75%
BFGoodrich Advantage
70%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
66%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
67%
Ride Comfort
Maxxis Premitra HP5
64%
BFGoodrich Advantage
72%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
90%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
64%
Economy
Maxxis Premitra HP5
52%
Maxxis
Premitra HP5
BFGoodrich Advantage
66%
BFGoodrich
Advantage
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
93%
Goodyear
Efficient Grip Performance 2
Toyo Proxes Comfort
58%
Toyo
Proxes Comfort
Rolling Resistance
Maxxis Premitra HP5
52%
BFGoodrich Advantage
71%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
85%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
57%
Mileage
Maxxis Premitra HP5
52%
BFGoodrich Advantage
60%
Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2
100%
Toyo Proxes Comfort
58%

Tests used in comparison

OrganizationSeasonYearDimension
AutobildAutobild
Summer
2024205/55 R16View
AutobildAutobild
Summer
2022215/55 R17View
FirmenautoFirmenauto
Summer
2021195/55 R16View
AutobildAutobild
Summer
2021205/55 R16View

Dimensions and prices

Compare prices across all available dimensions for these tyres.

View general comparison

Add to comparison

Popular brands
New comparison