Comparing the Maxxis Premitra AS AP3 and the Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3 across independent tests shows a clear performance gap. The Maxxis Premitra AS AP3 (our rating: 53%, made in CN; manufacturer: Maxxis) scores respectably in a few areas but lags in overall balance. The Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3 (our rating: 81%, made in SI/FR; manufacturer: Goodyear) is consistently ranked near the top for all-season performance.
Replacement status: Neither model lists a newer tyre that replaced it.
Summary of test results
Across Autobild and ACE comparative tests, the Vector 4Seasons Gen-3 ranks much higher: Autobild placed the Goodyear at
4th of 32 versus the Maxxis at
13th. In ACE tests the Vector sits at
3rd of 9 while the Maxxis is
7th. Independent lab summaries (TyreReviews / TyreReviews.com 2025) echo the same pattern: Goodyear praised for
best-in-class wet handling, dry handling, snow capability, comfort and low exterior noise, while Maxxis earns praise mainly for
aquaplaning resistance and some wet handling strengths but shows weaknesses in wet braking, comfort and rolling resistance.
Strengths — Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3
- Balanced performance: top-tier wet and dry handling in multiple tests and very good snow traction/braking.
- Comfort & noise: repeatedly noted as one of the quietest and most comfortable all-season tyres.
- Durability / mileage: Autobild and ACE highlight higher mileage and good wear characteristics.
- Test position consistency: High placements across independent test suites (4/32, 3/9).
Weaknesses — Goodyear
- Aquaplaning: several sources note reduced aquaplaning resistance versus the very best in that metric.
- Rolling resistance: slightly above-average rolling resistance (impacts fuel efficiency).
Strengths — Maxxis Premitra AS AP3
- Aquaplaning resistance: highlighted repeatedly as a key advantage (very good longitudinal and cross aquaplaning behavior).
- Wet cornering & handling: good performance in wet circle and dynamic wet tests.
- Value: offers good safety margins in a few critical wet conditions for a lower price point.
Weaknesses — Maxxis
- Overall balance: lower overall rating and mid-to-lower placements in comparative tests.
- Wet braking & snow handling: average wet braking and imprecise snow handling; understeer reported under many conditions.
- Comfort & efficiency: average comfort and high rolling resistance; limited mileage compared with premium rivals.
Verdict
Overall winner: Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3. Test positions and aggregated ratings clearly favor the Goodyear as the more rounded all-season tyre — better wet and dry handling, superior comfort and lower noise, and higher mileage. The Maxxis Premitra AS AP3 is a competent budget all-rounder with standout aquaplaning resistance and some wet handling strengths, but it falls short on wet braking, snow precision, comfort and fuel efficiency.
Recommendation: if you want the best all-season balance, comfort and test-proven performance, choose the Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3. If budget and aquaplaning resistance are your priorities and you accept trade-offs in rolling resistance and snow precision, the Maxxis Premitra AS AP3 remains a viable option.
