Comparison: Kumho Ecsta HS52 vs. Dunlop SP Sport MAXX RT2 vs. Michelin Primacy 5

In this comparison, we are going to look into the performance of two leading summer tires: the Kumho Ecsta HS52 and the Dunlop SP Sport MAXX RT2.

Starting with the Kumho Ecsta HS52, it comes from the tire manufacturer Kumho and serves as a successor to the popular Kumho Ecsta HS51 model. It comes highly rated, standing at 78% in our integrated ranking system, placing it as a formidable choice in the touring sub-type category. The tire demonstrates optimal strength in mileage and wet circle cornering in the ADAC test. It finishes impressively at the third position out of 16 tested tyres, cementing its place as a top performer. Autobild also echoes ADAC's findings where it stands out for its price-value ratio and dry braking capabilities. However, it slightly underperforms in aquaplaning, indicating room for improvement.

On the other hand, the Dunlop SP Sport MAXX RT2, emanating from the well-known tire manufacturer Dunlop, is considered a premium Ultra-High-Performance summer tire. Despite a lower rating of 72% compared to the Kumho Ecsta HS52, this tyre excels in certain areas. In the ADAC test, the tire performs well in flooded conditions, reflected in its aquaplaning - cross capabilities. Further, Autobild elevates its performance on the comfort front and lonitudal aquaplaning capability, establishing it as a strong contender even within a highly competitive field of 51 tested tyres. The delay in steering response on dry tracks demonstrates a potential weak point in its performance.

In summarising, the Kumho Ecsta HS52 scores high in being a balanced, fuel-efficient tire with superior handling capabilities on dry and wet roads but shows slight weaknesses in aquaplaning performance.

The Dunlop SP Sport MAXX RT2 shines in the areas of aquaplaning characteristics, precise wet handling, and braking performance on both wet and dry surfaces and good ride comfort. However, a delayed steering response on dry tarmac needs to be kept into consideration.

Based on integrated ranking and individual test performances, the Kumho Ecsta HS52 seems to be the winner as the overall balanced and efficient tyre. However, the Dunlop SP Sport MAXX RT2 should not be disregarded for scenarios demanding high-performance aquaplaning mitigation and ride comfort.

It's recommended to make your tire selection based on your specific driving conditions and requirements while considering the aforementioned strengths and weaknesses of each tyre.