Comparison: Kleber Quadraxer 3 vs. Michelin CrossClimate 2 vs. GoodYear UltraGrip Performance+ vs. Dunlop Winter

When comparing the Kleber Quadraxer 3 and the Michelin CrossClimate 2, the overall picture from multiple independent tyre tests is clear: both are strong all-round contenders, but they target slightly different priorities. Our aggregated ratings reflect this: Kleber 81% vs Michelin 92%.

Test summary and mutual positions
Across Autobild and TyreReviews results, the two tyres swap places depending on the test focus. In one Autobild test (15 tyres) the Kleber finished higher (4th) while the Michelin was 9th. In a larger Autobild comparison (37 tyres) the Michelin placed 4th and the Kleber 7th. Independent reviews (TyreReviews and TyreReviews.com) repeatedly highlight the Michelin as a test winner for overall performance, especially in dry braking and snow performance. In short: Kleber can outrun Michelin in specific scenarios (value and some snow/comfort aspects), but Michelin is the more consistent top performer across tests.

Strengths — Michelin CrossClimate 2

• Exceptional overall performance: consistently top-ranking in independent tests and listed as a test winner.


• Excellent dry braking and dynamic dry handling — one of the best in class.


• Top-tier snow braking, snow traction and fast snow-handling lap times.


• Low rolling resistance and pleasant ride comfort; good aquaplaning reserves.


• High score for durability and mileage in several tests.

Weaknesses — Michelin CrossClimate 2

• Average wet braking and wet handling in some tests — competent but not class-leading on wet roads.


• Higher purchase price compared with many rivals.

Strengths — Kleber Quadraxer 3

• Very good value-for-money with convincing driving behaviour on snow and ice.


• Short dry braking distances and strong aquaplaning reserves reported in several tests.


• Comfortable ride and low exterior noise are frequently praised.


• Often highlighted for snow handling and snow braking — a winter-capable choice at lower cost.

Weaknesses — Kleber Quadraxer 3

• Tendency to understeer on dry and sometimes on wet roads; delayed steering response noted in tests.


• Less consistent in overall rankings compared with premium all-rounders like the CrossClimate 2.

Verdict — which to pick?
If you want the most consistently high-performing all-round tyre with outstanding dry performance, low rolling resistance and top snow scores, the Michelin CrossClimate 2 is the safer premium choice — reflected by its higher overall rating and multiple test wins. If you prioritise value, comfort and strong winter capability for a lower price, the Kleber Quadraxer 3 delivers excellent snow performance and good safety reserves, albeit with compromises in wet steering precision.

Note: Neither model in our data set has been replaced by a newer generation at the time of these tests.