Comparison: Fulda MultiControl vs. Toyo Celsius AS2

The following comparison looks at test results and real-world strengths of the Fulda MultiControl and the Toyo Celsius AS2, two all‑round (all‑season) tyres evaluated in multiple AutoBild tests. For manufacturer information see Fulda and Toyo. Neither model in our data has been replaced by a newer listed successor.

Headlines from the tests

• Toyo Celsius AS2 consistently finished in the upper mid‑pack: 13th/35 and 12th/37 in AutoBild test runs. Test summaries praise its comfort, price/value and aquaplaning resistance, and also note low exterior noise.


• Fulda MultiControl placed near the back of evaluated grids (31/35 and 27/37). Our internal score for Fulda is very low (3%), while the Toyo scores markedly higher at 54% in our rating system.

Aggregated test findings — Toyo Celsius AS2

• Strengths: repeated praise for high mileage and a very good price‑to‑performance ratio (AutoBild 2022/2024/2025). Aquaplaning reserves are consistently described as good, and reviewers highlight comfort and low exterior noise.


• Weaknesses: winter and wet handling are not perfect — reports note understeer and delayed steering response on wet/slushy surfaces, and somewhat extended wet braking distances. Summaries call the winter qualities “average.”


• Overall positioning: a solid, economical all‑season choice that excels on mileage, noise and aquaplaning but sacrifices a bit of sharpness and wet braking performance compared with the best in class.

Aggregated test findings — Fulda MultiControl

• Strengths: test data and feature lists for this model are limited in our dataset; it did not score well in the reported AutoBild lineups.


• Weaknesses: consistently low placements (near the bottom of the test fields) and a very low overall rating indicate shortcomings across the key areas measured in the tests — wet performance, handling and overall test scoring. Given the results, the tyre struggles to match competitors on safety and performance metrics.


• Overall positioning: not recommended based on the provided comparative tests; performance appears inferior to most rivals in the same test fields.

Mutual test positions and which tyre is better
Across the common AutoBild tests, Toyo Celsius AS2 was clearly the better performer — finishing roughly a dozen places higher in comparable test grids and showing significantly better overall scoring in our database (54% vs 3%). Toyo leads in comfort, value and aquaplaning performance, while Fulda is consistently near the rear of the pack. In head‑to‑head comparisons based on the available results, the Toyo is the recommended choice for drivers seeking an economical, long‑lasting all‑season tyre with good aquaplaning resistance and low noise. If maximum wet braking precision and sharper winter handling are priorities, consider looking at higher‑ranked alternatives in recent test lists.

Verdict
For most buyers wanting a balanced all‑season tyre with strong mileage and good value, the Toyo Celsius AS2 is the better pick. The Fulda MultiControl shows poor test placements and a very low score in our dataset, so it cannot be recommended based on the reported tests. For brand information visit Toyo and Fulda.