Comparison: Firestone Roadhawk vs. Maxxis Premitra HP5 vs. Goodyear Efficient Grip Performance 2 vs. Semperit Speed-Life 3

If you're agonizing over the right summer tyres for your vehicle, you might consider Firestone Roadhawk and Maxxis Premitra HP5. Both come from reputable manufacturers, namely Firestone and Maxxis, and offer commendable performance concerning various features.

Firestone Roadhawk

The Firestone Roadhawk has reportedly achieved an overall performance rating of 72%. Praised as per Autobild's test for its robust dry and wet handling attributes and excellent wet side guide. It earned the third spot among 51 tyres. Additionally, Autozeitung appreciates the swift dry steering response, whereas ACE highlights its noteworthy rolling resistance.

Despite its strengths, a few weaknesses were pinpointed as well. The major drawback being elevated rolling noise as stated in the ADAC 2018 test summary. A vital point to remember is this model has not been replaced by a newer tyre and remains a top choice for many drivers.

Maxxis Premitra HP5

Compared to Firestone Roadhawk, Maxxis Premitra HP5 exhibits a higher ranking with an 81% total score. Among 51 tyres on the Autobild test, it secured the 9th position acknowleding aquaplaning- cross and aquaplaning- longitudal attributes. Not to forget, it captured the first place amongst nine tyres in the ACE test—specifically appreciated for aquaplaning, dry braking and handling alongside wet handling.

However, this model has its downsides too as stated by ADAC's 2018 test summary—delayed steering response and mediocre grip level on both dry and wet roads. Furthermore, it demonstrated limited lifespan and high rolling resistance as per the Autobild 2022 test. Yet, this tyre hasn't been replaced with a newer one.

Conclusion

Regardless of test grades, the optimal tyre depends on your driving requirements as both Firestone Roadhawk and Maxxis Premitra HP5 showcase potent and weak attributes. For top-notch wet and dry handling, Firestone Roadhawk stands out, whereas for aquaplaning and excellent dry braking, the Maxxis Premitra HP5 shines. Therefore, carefully weigh your driving habits and vehicle's technical specs before making a decision.