Comparison: Esa+Tecar Spirit Pro vs. Semperit Speed-Life 3

Tyre comparison has become so much better now that we have products like the Esa+Tecar Spirit Pro and the Semperit Speed-Life 3 on the market. Both these tyres are summer models, promising good performance in dry and wet conditions.

The Esa+Tecar Spirit Pro is a respected tyre in the market, but it doesn't have any previous models as it's the first of its kind. We have given it an overall rating of 65%, a decent score indicating it’s a trustworthy tyre. A highlight of this tyre is the mileage, as it stood 7th in the ADAC test, impressing with its robust usability. Its overall performance was promising, however, some drawbacks were noted. According to ADAC 2024 and 2021 tests results, while it performed well in wet conditions, its performance on dry surfaces left room for improvement.

In contrast, the Semperit Speed-Life 3 is the heir of the Semperit Speed-Life, maintaining the legacy of the Semperit brand, a manufacturer known for its quality summer tyres. This particular model scooped a respectable rating of 59% from us. It ranked 10th in the ADAC test and showed impressive mileage and wet braking. However, similar to the Esa+Tecar Spirit Pro, it was noted for considerable weaknesses on dry surfaces in both 2024 and 2021 ADAC tests results. Additionally, it showed downsides in its environmental footprint.

In conclusion, these summer tyres show strong performances with some areas for improvement. Both tyres showed good mileage and wet condition performance. The Esa+Tecar Spirit Pro scored higher in our rating and in the ADAC test, however, the Semperit Speed-Life 3 should not be dismissed as it also brings reliable features to the table. Their major shared weakness remains their performance on dry roads. Overall, your choice between the two will depend on your specific needs and priorities.